Growth Frameworks
Jobs To Be Done

The Cost of Marketing the Wrong Job to Be Done

Qualitative Exploration

The Cost of Marketing the Wrong Job to Be Done

Introduction

Every product on the market exists to solve a problem, fulfill a need, or improve someone’s life. But what if the reason people buy your product isn't the reason you're marketing it? This is where the concept of 'Jobs to Be Done' (JTBD) becomes crucial. It goes beyond features and benefits to ask: what job is the customer actually hiring this product to do? When companies misunderstand that job – or market the wrong one – the consequences can be costly. Think confused consumers, low engagement, missed targets, and stalled growth. And the fix isn’t bigger budgets or louder campaigns. It’s deeper understanding.
This blog post explores what happens when organizations make the wrong assumptions about customer intent – and how aligning marketing with the true 'job to be done' can shift the entire trajectory of a brand. Whether you're a business leader responsible for go-to-market strategy, a product team shaping innovation, or a marketer fine-tuning messaging, understanding this misalignment is key. We'll share real-world marketing missteps where messaging missed the point, and explain why customer insights – especially qualitative ones – are the key to avoiding them. If you’ve ever asked why your product messaging isn’t working or wondered how to better connect with your target audience, this post is for you. At SIVO Insights, we help brands avoid these pitfalls through customized consumer research and human-centered insight. In the following sections, we’ll break down the cost of marketing the wrong product job, showcase Jobs to Be Done examples in marketing, and highlight how a clear understanding of consumer motivation supports stronger product-market fit and better brand strategy.
This blog post explores what happens when organizations make the wrong assumptions about customer intent – and how aligning marketing with the true 'job to be done' can shift the entire trajectory of a brand. Whether you're a business leader responsible for go-to-market strategy, a product team shaping innovation, or a marketer fine-tuning messaging, understanding this misalignment is key. We'll share real-world marketing missteps where messaging missed the point, and explain why customer insights – especially qualitative ones – are the key to avoiding them. If you’ve ever asked why your product messaging isn’t working or wondered how to better connect with your target audience, this post is for you. At SIVO Insights, we help brands avoid these pitfalls through customized consumer research and human-centered insight. In the following sections, we’ll break down the cost of marketing the wrong product job, showcase Jobs to Be Done examples in marketing, and highlight how a clear understanding of consumer motivation supports stronger product-market fit and better brand strategy.

Why Identifying the Correct Job to Be Done Matters in Marketing

Understanding the 'Job to Be Done' shifts how marketing works. Instead of just highlighting what a product is, JTBD marketing focuses on why a customer chooses it – what outcome they’re looking for, and what role the product plays in their life. When that alignment is clear, marketing resonates. Without it, brands often waste time and money speaking to the wrong needs.

What Happens When You Misunderstand the Job?

Marketing the wrong job to be done can create a disconnect between your message and your market. This mismatch often leads to:

  • Poor product-market fit: Your product might be sound, but if the messaging doesn’t reflect what the audience cares about, it won’t land.
  • Confused consumers: When prospects can't see how a product helps them in a meaningful way, they walk away.
  • Underperforming campaigns: Even the best creative work can struggle when it's built on the wrong assumptions.

Imagine You Sell a Blender...

Say you launch a high-powered blender. You market it as an appliance for food prep – a tool for cooking at home. Logical, right? But deep consumer insights might reveal that many buyers are purchasing it to support a new healthy lifestyle. In this case, they're hiring the blender to help them feel healthier, make daily habits easier, or support a weight-loss journey. Product messaging that speaks only to kitchen utility misses that emotional job entirely.

Why Jobs to Be Done Fuels Better Marketing Strategy

By identifying the right job to be done, brands can shape messaging that meets consumers where they are – functionally, emotionally, and aspirationally. It also refines every part of the customer journey:

1. Clearer Target Audience Insights

Knowing the job sheds light on who your audience truly is and what matters to them. It's not just demographics, but motivations and use contexts.

2. Stronger Brand Positioning

Instead of fighting for attention in a crowded category, you define your space by highlighting the unique value of your product’s role.

3. Better Product Launches

When your messaging aligns with the customer's job from the start, adoption is faster and feedback is more useful for iteration.

4. More Effective Messaging

No more guesswork. Your messaging speaks directly to customer emotion and intention – something even the best features can’t do alone.

At SIVO Insights, our market research approach helps uncover these foundational jobs, using qualitative and quantitative tools that go deeper than surface-level data. When brands understand what their product is truly being hired to do, they create more focused, impactful campaigns – and avoid the costly trap of misaligned messaging.

Common Reasons Brands Misinterpret Customer Intent

Many marketing failures can be traced back to one central issue: assuming you know your customer better than you actually do. When companies misunderstand the real reason a consumer buys their product—or the Job to Be Done—they risk misaligned messaging, missed opportunities, and weakened product-market fit. But why does this happen?

Here are the most common reasons brands get customer intent wrong:

1. Relying Too Heavily on Demographics

Segmenting your audience by age, income, or location can be helpful for targeting, but these data points don’t uncover why someone is hiring your product. Two people with similar profiles can buy the same product for completely different reasons. Without understanding the true consumer motivation, it's easy to target the wrong message.

2. Confusing Product Benefits With Customer Needs

It’s common to focus on features and assume their value is self-evident. But features are not jobs. For example, selling a blender as “high-speed and stainless steel” says nothing about the buyer who needs it to prep quick meals between meetings. Marketing must connect the product’s benefits to a real, emotional or functional customer need.

3. Internal Echo Chambers

Companies often form narratives about their customers based on internal opinions rather than research. Over time, these assumptions solidify and get baked into brand strategy—even if they’re outdated. Without ongoing target audience insights, teams can market based on what they want to be true, rather than what is.

4. Rushing to Market Without Listening

When time and resources are tight, it's tempting to launch a product with a generalized message. But skipping deeper consumer insights research can lead to ineffective positioning from day one. This is one of the fastest ways to lose trust and stall growth.

5. Treating Everyone the Same

A one-size-fits-all approach ignores that different people may hire your product for entirely different Jobs to Be Done. By flattening the jobs into a single narrative, brands sacrifice relevance and personalization, reducing their impact with each segment.

Understanding customer behavior isn’t about guessing—it’s about listening. And that begins with asking the right questions to uncover the actual role your product plays in someone’s life.

How Jobs to Be Done Research Prevents Mismarketing

When done correctly, Jobs to Be Done research serves as a powerful safeguard against mismarketing. It shifts the focus from selling products to solving problems—problems your customers genuinely care about. By identifying the real reason a person chooses your product, this approach strengthens the connection between your message, your product, and your market.

JTBD Research Reveals Motivation Over Assumptions

Unlike surface-level surveys that focus on preferences or opinions, JTBD interviews dig into context, emotion, and decision-making timelines. They answer deeper questions, such as:

  • What triggered the customer's search for a solution?
  • What other options did they consider?
  • What outcome were they hoping to achieve?
  • What concerns almost prevented them from buying?

This helps you uncover the true consumer motivation—the kind of insights that fuel both strategic clarity and creative inspiration.

Why Misaligned Messaging Costs More Than You Think

Misunderstanding the customer’s job leads to messaging that confuses rather than convinces. When your ads don’t speak to the problem your audience is trying to solve, they scroll past. Worse, they may choose a competitor who better reflects their needs. The cost of misaligned marketing messages isn’t just lower conversion – it’s lost relevance and market traction.

Results of Clear JTBD Research in Market Launches

How Jobs to Be Done improves product launches often comes down to this: relevance. When your messaging directly reflects how your product fits into the buyer’s life, they not only pay attention—they remember you. JTBD research brings clarity to who you’re marketing to, what you’re solving, and how to communicate it effectively.

Some additional benefits include:

  • Reducing wasted spending on ineffective campaigns
  • Identifying unmet needs that inspire product innovation
  • Creating alignment across marketing, design, and product teams

Ultimately, JTBD helps your brand strategy become more human—and more profitable. This kind of research doesn’t just protect you from mistakes; it empowers better decisions across the board.

Aligning Your Product Positioning With the Right Customer Job

Knowing the Job to Be Done is only half the battle – the real impact comes when you use that insight to shape your product messaging and brand positioning. This is where market research turns into measurable results.

From Insight to Positioning

The job your customer is hiring your product to do should be the foundation of your marketing. It tells you what to say, how to say it, and who to say it to. Here’s how to turn those insights into action:

Clarify the Core Promise

The core promise of your brand isn’t just about your features—it’s about the outcome you enable. For instance, a camera company might talk about specs, but for a parent capturing their child’s first steps, the real job is about preserving a fleeting, emotional moment. Understanding customer needs through JTBD ensures your messaging connects directly with what matters most.

Speak the Customer’s Language

Effective messaging uses words your target audience would actually use. JTBD research gives you access to these phrases directly from the consumer’s voice. This reduces the risk of using industry terms that feel irrelevant or confusing to the people you want to reach. The best marketing doesn’t just describe the product – it mirrors the customer’s situation.

Test and Evolve

The best positioning strategies stay flexible. As market needs evolve, so do the jobs your product might serve. Continuous consumer insights help you refine and adapt without losing touch with your audience. Companies that remain tightly aligned with user needs are better equipped to maintain product-market fit over time.

Realignment in Action

For example, consider a fitness tracker originally marketed for athletes. Through JTBD research, the brand discovered many users were busy parents tracking basic movement or sleep – not extreme workouts. By repositioning towards daily health monitoring and reducing the emphasis on high-performance metrics, adoption increased across broader demographics.

This shift didn’t require a product overhaul—just a different way to talk about the same strengths in a context that mattered more.

That’s the power of aligning your strategy with the right Job to Be Done. It ensures your solution appears not just available, but entirely relevant in the customer’s world.

Summary

When marketing misses the real reason people buy, even a great product can fall flat. As we've seen from real-world examples and brand missteps, assumptions around consumer behavior often lead to misaligned campaigns, weak positioning, and stalled growth. The link between Jobs to Be Done and marketing success lies in truly understanding the functional and emotional reasons behind a purchase decision.

By investing in smart, qualitative market research, businesses can uncover the true drivers of choice—shaping strategies that connect, convert, and endure. Whether you're launching a new product, evaluating your messaging, or refining your target strategy, identifying the right Job to Be Done ensures that your efforts are grounded in what people actually need – not what you assume they want.

Effective marketing doesn’t need more noise—it needs more empathy and insight.

Summary

When marketing misses the real reason people buy, even a great product can fall flat. As we've seen from real-world examples and brand missteps, assumptions around consumer behavior often lead to misaligned campaigns, weak positioning, and stalled growth. The link between Jobs to Be Done and marketing success lies in truly understanding the functional and emotional reasons behind a purchase decision.

By investing in smart, qualitative market research, businesses can uncover the true drivers of choice—shaping strategies that connect, convert, and endure. Whether you're launching a new product, evaluating your messaging, or refining your target strategy, identifying the right Job to Be Done ensures that your efforts are grounded in what people actually need – not what you assume they want.

Effective marketing doesn’t need more noise—it needs more empathy and insight.

In this article

Why Identifying the Correct Job to Be Done Matters in Marketing
Common Reasons Brands Misinterpret Customer Intent
How Jobs to Be Done Research Prevents Mismarketing
Aligning Your Product Positioning With the Right Customer Job

In this article

Why Identifying the Correct Job to Be Done Matters in Marketing
Common Reasons Brands Misinterpret Customer Intent
How Jobs to Be Done Research Prevents Mismarketing
Aligning Your Product Positioning With the Right Customer Job

Last updated: May 25, 2025

Curious how Jobs to Be Done insights can elevate your marketing strategy?

Curious how Jobs to Be Done insights can elevate your marketing strategy?

Curious how Jobs to Be Done insights can elevate your marketing strategy?

At SIVO Insights, we help businesses understand people.
Let's talk about how we can support you and your business!

SIVO On Demand Talent is ready to boost your research capacity.
Let's talk about how we can support you and your team!

Your message has been received.
We will be in touch soon!
Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Please try again or contact us directly at contact@sivoinsights.com